Ethical Leadership: Expressions and Effects

“I am resigning from my post, effective immediately…” – This line from an email sent by a Fortune 500 company CEO left a permanent impression on how people see ethical leadership, especially in a global business context. At the time when Mark Hurd got luridly mired in several ethics-related scandals that led to his public demise from Hewlett-Packard (O’Brien, 2010), open conversations on corporate scandals and controversial moral dilemmas became judiciously relevant, especially to its employees, I included, who witnessed how the stories metamorphosed.

When horrible faces of unethical leadership step into the limelight, we cannot help but ask ourselves, what are the beautiful expressions of ethical leadership?

Ethical Leadership

Akin to a combination of transformational and transformative leadership in terms of goal (communicate truth), focus (in support of status quo), and purpose (promote goodness), ethical leadership is a commitment to the inner and outer drive of the leader’s social responsibilities in pursuing the common good (Grace and Grace, 1999). Ethical leadership exude a strong 4Vs character baseline (values, virtue, vision, voice) that embraces sensitive integration and understanding of certain levels of ethical analysis (individual morality of leaders, means of leadership, leadership mission) (Palmer, 2009). Moreover, ethical leadership serves as a unifying factor in cultures and mindsets (Connelley and Tripodi, 2012). In a recent empirical investigation in Singapore, ethical leadership is meaningfully interspersed with effectiveness, satisfaction, and positive organizational culture outcomes (Toor and Ofori, 2009).

Ethical Leaders

Ethical leaders profoundly extend their current ways of thinking on emotions, congruence, and identification of proper organizational behaviours (Brown and Mitchell, 2010). Whether in the Western or Eastern societal clusters, a more all-inclusive representation on ethically leading across cross-cultural and cross-sectoral commonalities and differences reveal that ethical leaders lean more into value-oriented perspectives (concern for responsibility/sustainability, honesty, integrity, people-orientation) (Eisenbeiß and Brodbeck, 2014). Because of the robust core self-evaluation that they default to, ethical leaders are proficient at invoking emotional linkages and influencing people engagement towards unquestionable moral actions and emotions (Zhang, Zhou, and Mao, 2018).

In highly changing and deeply competitive global landscapes, where continuous positive adoption to a culture of readiness and structure is vital, it is inevitable to have responsiveness barriers relating to dishonesty, corruption, egocentrism, manipulation, and other morality-related and (Metwally et al., 2019); it may be a choice of some to pursue unethical leadership options to reduce uncertainty. Nevertheless, ethical leaders are those who prove that it is possible to find purpose in enhancing readiness to change in direct, honourable, and positive ways that can shape cultures of certainty and value. Some of the most prominent ethical leaders that we know of are Sheryl Sandberg, Confucius, Bill Gates, Jesus, and Barack Obama.

Ethical Leadership Effects

As antecedents, analyses, and consequences reveal, particularly in the workplace setting, despite ethical cultures and pressures surrounding leadership, ethical leaders get and stay ahead because they exhibit superior potential for promotability, both in near-term and long-term contexts (Rubin, Dierdorff, and Brown, 2010). Empirical research has shown that ethical leadership builds social learning through enforcing ethical behaviours, facilitating empathy-enabling processes, and establishing effective relationships amongst peers; as a result, cognitive, relational, and structural breadths of social capital are generated successfully through ethical leadership (Pastoriza and Ariño, 2013). Likewise, there is a positive effect on employee-organization commitment (organizational deviance is low) when the leader’s reputation is perceived as with high moral standards (Neves and Story, 2015).

With openly constructive prosocial motivations and conscientiousness effects on relationships, ethical leadership also supports the social learning theory (behaviours, environmental/personal factors) in terms of strong dutifulness (Xia and Yang, 2020). This can be correlated not only with organizational support from an individual point of view but also towards positive cross-level effects on the team’s morale and performance. Furthermore, empirical data show that ethical leaders have helped transform organizations in irreversibly good ways, by enabling, influencing, and sustaining ethical approaches toward issues, culture building, and social movements in complex settings (Cortellazo, Bruni, and Zampieri, 2019).

Reflection

Just like Meg Whitman, the CEO who succeeded Mark Hurd, the way she advocated for ethical practices in every inch of the decision she made, strategically demonstrated ethical leadership in a way that inspired resilience, performance, and enablement for Hewlett-Packard to get back on track.

Societal and demographic shifts because of globalization, unprecedented challenges, tempting acts, and pressing issues can trigger impressions on the soundness of pursuing unethical leadership. This however does not mean that it is and that it certainly can be, right. Ethical leadership is irreplaceable, and the focus on purpose (values, virtue, vision, voice) and goal on every leadership dealing are relevant and significant. Ethical leaders are the role models of value-oriented perspectives, and they can spark sustainable high moral standards and performance that are truly coveted, no matter what conversation, controversy, or context it may be.

What is your ethical leadership story? Does it involve an “I am resigning from my post, effective immediately…”? Does it ignite emotional fervour and moral actions?

This blogpost is intended to be interactive, so feel free to leave a comment in the section below or, alternatively, you can send a request to find out more about the academic references used in this article.

10 thoughts on “Ethical Leadership: Expressions and Effects

  1. Thank you for the insightful views on the importance of ethical leadership in moder
    business. The case study about HP’s CEO Meg Whitman is a very good example of ethtical implication in practice.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great post Eldrin! Well explained ethical leadership and how it impacts the workplace. This is most of the organizations pitfalls for they overlooked this important part of leadership, being ethical. And it’s good to know that there are leaders like Whitman. I enjoyed the flow and structure of your post. I will look out for your next blogs!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks Eldrin for sharing the useful article about Ethical Leadership. I am truly agreed the theories of 4Vs that should be the values that adhere by the ethical leadership. The example of a ethical leadership in HP is precisely articulated the right leadership applied and executed in the business introduced a few strategic directions. Very informative after the whole article reading and looking forward more from Eldrin.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. That is very informative. I like what you wrote on this, a lot. I had agreed with the reflection. We can no longer ignore the strong link between work ethics, employee performance, and future success!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Completely agree with the importance of values, virtue, vision, and voice in leadership. In my opinion, one can’t be without the other to form a true leader.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Great blog!! Eldrin, I love the way how you started the topic with Mark Hurd’s opening quote and told a story of ethical leadership succession which bought the company back to the right track and truly believing the power of good prevails again!!!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Many would think that taking a CEO resigning is taking responsibility for the mistake but on the other hand the difficult task would be to remain and step up to fix the issue. Thank you for the insightful article.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Very insightful! And I completely agree with you. I’ve witnessed ethical leadership in action and how it positively impacted the team’s performance and morale. Leading with purpose is very important in this time when most of the organisations are facing a lot of uncertainties.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create your website with WordPress.com
Get started
%d bloggers like this: